KazPad
I had heard that Massimov asked the cabinet of Ministers to buy iPads but hadn’t realized it had started a mad trend.
While I don’t think it’s a bad idea for the government to embrace technology, the reason given (that he wants to send them messages at any time) doesn’t seem to justify the expense. Every one in Kazakhstan has a cellphone. All the higher government officials have the latest Nokia, and iPhone and probably an extra cellphone or two lying around. So they can be reached by email, text, and of course, phone calls 24 hours a day. So I’m not clear what the iPads add in terms of value.
A second issue is security. I know Blackberry’s come with heavy-duty encryption which is why Obama gets to have one. I don’t think iPads are so heavily encrypted. I won’t encourage any techies out there want to test my theory by setting something up near the government buildings but perhaps the KNB or KazSatNet should do some field testing first. Also you may remember this incident when 11400 iPad users may have been put at risk due to a security breach at Apple. Now one assumes that the government has already thought of this, and probably wouldn’t reveal any extra security precautions they might be taking.
Now, I know many people who work in government who would love to see more technology use and less paperwork. From what I hear, printing out memos and orders and graphs and databases for non-tech savy bosses, or because every document has to have a stamp and a signature on it, wastes a lot of paper and time. So if government start getting into the habit of sharing files electronically, it would cut way back on the ecological impact of the bureaucracy and increase efficiency. So let’s hope these reforms are moving in the direction of less paper and barriers and more free flows of information.
There’s a simple explanation to that: half of all the news concerning government initiatives in KZ are Russian news with a month-or-two time lag. You can easily google the “bring-your-iPads story” involving Medvedev – it happened in September. The same would be with the establishment of the “local Silicon Valley” and many-many others. It seems like Kazakhstani govt tends to try on Russian ideas, when it lacks its own ones.
Which in turn come from the US or the West. Apparently Massimov went to some meeting somewhere and saw all the officials with Blackberrys and iPhones and iPads and was afraid the Kazakhstany would look bad with nothing more than their 5 Nokia phones!
Yeah, iPhones/iPads do come from the West, but the whole thing of telling your subordinates in public that they must have one and “bring it to the class tomorrow” is quite an Eastern invention, I guess.
For me it’s a token gesture saying: “Modernization is under way and we’re leading it.” They may well forget about those iPods the next day.
And the subordinates saying, “Yes, sir” and then go out and do it, is also an Eastern thing. It’s definitely a token thing since the people at that level have probably never used a computer in their lives. Let alone an iPad.
[…] in December of 2010 there was a lot of noise about the Prime Minister’s insistencethat all Ministers have an iPad, and Arta announced at that time that they would release their own tablet computer. A press release […]